Back in 2014 I purchased my first pair of "good" wading boots, Simms Freestones. I wore them for four years and have probably 75-80 days on stream with these boots. They were bullet proof from day one and have held up pretty well considering. But they started to show a bit of wear and tear, and I desired a second pair of boots to have available to swap out on multi-day trips.

Late last fall The Driftless Angler fly shop made me a deal I couldn't refuse on a new pair, so I took the plunge. The new Freestones are just as tough as the old ones, and just a bit more comfortable. They broke in nicely after a couple of outings and I expect them to last for many years rotating them with the old boots.

Here's some shots of the old boots showing some of the wear and tear. But they are still more than fine for everyday use.


The lining around the top of the boot wore away, but doesn't affect anything other than looks. The orange interior lining is completely intact with no excessive wear apparent.


I was a little hesitant when I bought the first pair, thinking the tread wouldn't grip well. But it turned out they do a great job in most conditions. And, they're easier to clean compared to deep tread soles. I've had few problems with them on rocks, mud and snow.


Here's the tread on the new pair after 10 outings this year. Hardly any wear on the old boots compared to the newer ones.


Improvements on the new boots include an improved top lining (that wore out on the old pair). The lace eyelets are also improved making it easier to remove and apply them. The laces on the new boots are also better than the replacement Simms branded ones I've bought for the old boots.



The lining is comfy, but I added a pair of waterproof insoles to tweak the fit a bit and add a touch of foot sole comfort. They're comfy enough to wear all day and provide superior ankle support and foot protection. I haven't had a single foot problem in the five seasons I've worn my Freestones.



These are excellent boots for the money (around $150) and are worth looking into if you seek a boot that will withstand a lot of abuse and still hold up well. I've seen them on sale at various outlets at the end of the last two seasons.


I should note that I always clean my boots out thoroughly after every outing, including removing the laces, insoles, and flushing the interior with water to remove all sand and grit. I feel this has greatly extended their life and reduces damage to my wader neoprene.


-Bill

Edited by user Tuesday, May 15, 2018 1:18:50 PM(UTC)  | Reason: edited photos

FYI;

I did not receive a discount or any other consideration for my review here of the Simms Freestones. I purchased my first pair at full price (from Cabelas) and my second pair at The Driftless Fly shop (on sale $20 off). When I like something and it works well I like to let others know.

I'm an expert at nothing - but I did stay at a Holiday Inn Express last night (no endorsement).




-Bill

Another thumbs up for the Freestones. Love mine.

I'm another staunch supporter of the freestone boot. I like the support and comfort even after hours on the water.

Felt is fading away pretty fast. It's really not a good idea around the DA as they can easily spread invasive bugs and plants. And as you said, they suck on mud and wet grass.

Be sure to call Mat or Geri at the Driftless Angler if you intend to buy any equipment on your next trip. While they have a nice selection, but may be temporarily out of stock on what you're looking for, or your size. I believe they can get almost anything delivered to the store in a day or two if you let them know in advance when you'll be there.

Simms also makes a boot called Vaportread which I've tried on. These are a lighter version of the Freestones with thinner sidewall material and are more like a lightweight hiking boot. Less protection for the sides of your foot, but probably more comfortable for walking longer distances on asphalt or gravel.

And yes, with boots always try them on for proper fit. The Simms Freestones are sized to wear with heavy neoprene boot waders. I'm a 10 4EEEE and they fit perfectly with the added insole. If you have a narrow foot, getting a proper fit might require adding an additional neoprene socks to compensate. They will be a little stiff to start with, but after you walk on them a day or two and get them wet a few times, they will break in smoothly.


-Bill